Don’t Burn Your Seedlings: Fertilizer Mistakes to Avoid

If you don’t want to burn seedlings, fertilizer should be applied appropriately. But it can be hard to know when, how, and what kind of feed is best. Experienced gardener, Sarah Jay, explains how to use fertilizers in a way that won’t harm your seedlings.

A close-up shot of a person placing a white bottle of liquid plant food, alongside other gardening tools and developing flowers, showcasing burn seedlings fertilizer

Contents

Among the ways to burn seedlings, fertilizer is number one. Seedlings are sensitive, tender plants that need gentle care before they’re transplanted. It’s important to be cautious when you fertilize them. And to be fair, fertilizing seedlings isn’t the easiest thing to grasp. 

Most of the confusion comes from the differences between feeding fully grown plants and applying fertilizers to seedling soils. You don’t need to use as much, and there’s a big difference in the timing. Knowing what type of fertilizer to use is another aspect that deserves attention.

All plants need essential macronutrients, which are present in all fertilizers. These are nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P), and potassium (K). Different plants need different ratios of these when they’re fruiting, but when they’re young, it’s good to keep things even so you don’t burn seedlings with fertilizer. An imbalance in this ratio can lead to problems.

The Ultimate Seed Starting Kit

The Ultimate Seed Starting Kit

Our Rating

The Ultimate Seed Starting Kit

The Premium Seed Starting Kit

The Premium Seed Starting Kit

Our Rating

The Premium Seed Starting Kit

The Essential Seed Starting Kit

The Essential Seed Starting Kit

Our Rating

The Essential Seed Starting Kit

Using the Wrong Kind of Fertilizer

Close-up of a man's hand pouring blue granular synthetic plant feed in the garden.
The type of fertilizer has an impact on strength.

The first mistake to avoid is using the wrong kind of fertilizer. This can burn seedlings. Fertilizer for seedlings should be balanced and preferably organic. Synthetic fertilizers can work, but they are derived from petroleum products and build salinity in the soil as they are continuously applied. 

Using fertilizers formulated for specific plants, or those designed to promote flowering and fruiting, isn’t necessary for seedlings. They need a balanced boost, rather than a specific formulation, as they’re in their vegetative stage rather than their fruiting and flowering stages.

Applying Before Germination

Close up of gardener's hand in blue glove holding handful of white granular plant feed applying it to soil in garden.
New seeds don’t need any feeding.

Seeds contain everything they need to grow. Seed starting mixes can contain organic matter, but seeds will grow in a soilless mix just fine. You don’t need to use feeds before germination, as this can burn seedlings. Fertilizer is best applied after seedlings reach three inches tall and develop their first set of true leaves. 

There’s a small caveat here: if you want to sprinkle a tablespoon of organic powdered fertilizer into your seedling mix, that is totally appropriate. It’s not completely necessary, but it won’t hurt. What does hurt is using liquid fertilizers too early, as there will be nothing to absorb them until your seedlings are mature enough. 

Using Too Much After Germination

An overhead and close-up shot of a person wearing blue colored gloves, applying granular plant feed on a developing young plant
Overdoing the fertilizer can damage the roots.

While seedlings need some fertility after they’re mature enough (at least a few inches tall), they don’t need a ton. Here’s where the timing of your applications comes in, and the type of fertilizer is important too. Use a liquid fertilizer diluted to one-quarter strength weekly to keep your seedlings healthy and happy. 

Remember to keep it balanced. A 10-10-10 (or similar ratio) is perfect. There are several OMRI-certified liquid fertilizers out there. If you don’t know which is best, find a good fish emulsion, which provides all the basic nutrients needed for seedlings in a gentle formulation. 

If you used a powder in your initial seed starting mix, it will be difficult to apply it again to seedlings as they grow. Even when you work this into the soil around plants already growing in the garden, you don’t use much. It’s too easy to overdo it with powders. Instead, stick to liquid. 

You can do what Jacques does, which involves watering the seedlings from the bottom with a bit of fertilizer thrown in. 

YouTube video

Waiting Too Long to Repot

A man's hands lift a tomato plant from a tray, showing that it's time to repot the seedlings into a larger pot.
Over time, seedlings use up available nutrients.

The reason for fertilizing seedlings has to do with the fertility in the amount of soil in your seedling trays. Over time, that little bit of seedling depletes the level of fertility as it uses it up to grow. By the time seedlings reach their true leaf stage, they appreciate a little boost to keep going.

Once seedlings grow two sets of true leaves, they should be transplanted, or they need to be up-potted. If you can’t transplant due to weather conditions, keep a few starter pots or even nursery pots nearby so you can repot your seedlings. Use a well-formulated potting soil with organic matter to supply the kind of nutrients seedlings need as they continue to mature. 

Compost is a blessing in this regard. You can use compost in your seed starting mix and in your repotting mix to provide a slow-release of nutrients throughout the seedlings’ time in those containers. It’s fine to combine compost with a diluted organic fertilizer, as both are bioavailable to plants, and both provide a slow leaching of nutrients, rather than packing a fertilizer punch all at once. 

Key Takeaways

While this concept is pretty simple once you understand the rules, it can be complicated. As you’re getting your seeds planted, or as you’re tending to them, remember the following:

  • Wait for seedlings to grow three inches tall and develop one set of true leaves to begin fertilizing, so you don’t burn seedlings with fertilizer.
  • Use an organic liquid fertilizer diluted to one-quarter strength, applied weekly in the watering process. 
  • Don’t overdo it, and try not to use synthetic or powdered ferts that are difficult to control or provide too much fertility all at once. 
  • When seedlings develop two sets of true leaves, they need to be repotted. Make sure to do this on time to have enough fertility for their continued maturation. 
  • Compost is your friend in both the seed starting mix and in the repotting process, if you want to not burn your seedlings with fertilizer.

Share This Post
A close-up shot of a small composition of potted plants and its fruits, all situated in a well lit area indoors, showcasing bottom heat seeds

Seeds

9 Seeds That Need Bottom Heat to Germinate

Some seeds germinate reliably at room temperature, but others need warmer soil to sprout within a reasonable timeframe. Gardening expert Madison Moulton shares nine common seeds that benefit from bottom heat and explains when it's worth the investment.

A close-up shot of a person in the process of assembling a black tray with soil and ovules. showcasing seed-starting zones 2-4

Seeds

Seed-Starting in Cold Climates: Tips for Zones 2-4

When it comes to seed starting, zones 2-4 may seem like a hard spot to do it. However, they are actually prime areas for seed starting if you know what to do! Experienced gardener Sarah Jay walks growers in these zones through a few tips to start seeds with ease.

A photo of a humidity domes germination, appearing to have small greens inside of the tray placed somewhere with indirect light

Seeds

How to Use Humidity Domes to Speed Up Seed Germination

If you’ve ever used them, you know that with humidity domes, germination improves. Choose the right dome, and you have seeds in optimal conditions for sprouting. Experienced gardener, Sarah Jay, discusses why domes are so effective and which ones to use.

Seed starting under lights, showing purple lights placed a top a layer of sprouts with rounded green leaves and whitish stems

Seeds

Seed Starting Under Lights: Getting a Jump on Winter Growing

Starting seeds indoors during winter gives you a head start on the growing season and expands the possibilities of what you can grow. Gardening expert Madison Moulton explains how to use grow lights for winter seed starting, from choosing what to plant to transplanting healthy seedlings.

An overhead and close-up shot of a person in the process of plants sprouted seeds, showcasing how to pre-sprout seeds

Seeds

How and Why to Pre-Sprout Seeds Before Growing

Every year, we gather our seeds and starting supplies to start the spring garden. If we’re dealing with old seeds or hard-to-germinate ones, we can use a fun trick to save ourselves some space and money! Experienced gardener Sarah Jay walks you through why and how to pre-sprout seeds for more success in spring.

An overhead and close-up shot of a person's hands holding a small pile of yellow seeds, showcasing january seed starting calendar

Seeds

January Seed-Starting Calendar: What to Start Week by Week

It’s time to prep your January seed starting calendar and get organized ahead of the spring season. No matter where you live and what kind of weather you expect for the beginning of the year, a good plan goes a long way. Experienced gardener Sarah Jay takes you through the month, week by week, to help you figure out what to do.