Should You Pull Up Annuals or Leave Them to Decompose in the Garden?

The first frost stops most annuals in their tracks. Should you pull out the spent plants or leave them in the ground over the winter? Gardening expert Melissa Strauss explores this idea and discusses the benefits and drawbacks of leaving them in the garden over the winter.

A gardener in bright blue sneakers and vibrant orange gloves uses a garden shovel to pull up dry dark brown annuals from an autumn garden, surrounded by fallen leaves and fading blooms.

Contents

As the temperature drops and living things begin to retreat for the winter, creating a clean slate in the garden can be tempting and satisfying. There are few things I like better than pulling everything out of a spent flower bed and hanging up my shovel for the Holidays. 

Annual crops, or those with a single-year life cycle, are usually discarded when the seasons shift. Anything that hasn’t dried up in the heat is likely to die off in the first frost. Then, you’re left with little more than dry, brown foliage where beautiful flowers bloomed just months before. 

There are plenty of reasons to get some tasks done while the weather is cool, and it’s wonderful to enjoy the outdoors. But wait! Before you start pulling, there just might be a better solution that is healthier for your space overall. 

Those single-year species may only be ornamental for a short while, but what about their contributions as they decompose? Is it better to pull them and dispose of them or to allow those annuals to remain in your beds?

The Short Answer

For the most part, leaving your spent annuals in the garden serves valuable purposes, and helps to maintain a healthy microbiome. There are exceptions, with plants that have damage from diseases or are susceptible to pests. For the most part, leaving them to decay in the garden is beneficial to the soil and its present and future inhabitants.

The Long Answer

It can be tempting to go out into the garden after a freeze and start pulling things that look unsightly. I struggle even before that time, to avoid pulling those annuals that the summer heat has rendered aesthetically displeasing.

Before you start pulling, though, I’d like to share some benefits of leaving those annuals to decompose in your garden over the winter. You might be surprised by how valuable that dead matter can be!

Benefits

A close-up reveals a vibrant strawberry plant thriving amidst a bed of French marigold, with wilted marigold leaves naturally mulching the base of the plant.
Let plants decompose naturally to enrich the soil.

If you consider the natural life cycles of plants, including annuals, it makes sense that you should typically leave them in the ground to decompose. After all, this is what happens to these annuals in their natural environments. If we look at the science behind it, there are some logical reasons to leave those plants to do their job. 

YouTube video

Improved Soil Structure

A lush maize field showcases tall, healthy plants thriving in neatly spaced rows, with remnants of previous crops and organic matter visible on the soil surface, characteristic of a no-till farming system.
Intact roots enrich soil and support beneficial garden ecosystems.

You’ve heard of no-till farming, which is when farmers cut their crops and cover crops to the ground but leave the roots intact. This has a valuable purpose, and it works the same way with your flower beds. 

The roots of your crops connect with each other, and help to maintain structure in the soil. This has a great number of beneficial effects on your garden. Leaving the roots intact supports the beneficial insects and microbes in the ground, which leads to an overall healthier environment. 

Pulling out the roots disrupts the ecosystem, often killing important organisms and closing channels and air pockets. Leaving them intact improves the soil’s ability to store water. It contributes organic matter, which breaks down into vital nutrients that will feed future plants. 

Additionally, those roots are great for preventing erosion and preserving the land in general. Leaving them in the ground will save money on fertilizer and soil replacement, and it will help conserve and maximize water use. 

Feed Wildlife

A group of birds perches on dry sunflower seed heads in a snow-dusted winter field.
Leaving flowers provides essential winter food for garden wildlife.

During the colder months, food becomes scarce for many of the animals that inhabit the garden. This is especially true for birds. Many of the insects they eat will hibernate or spend winter in their larval or pupal stages, tucked away out of reach. The fruits of summer are in short supply, and birds and other small animals will only stick around if they can find what they need. 

When you pull up your annuals, there are less food sources. But if you leave flowers to go to seed and remain in the ground, they create a supply of food for wildlife. Annual flowers like zinnias, sunflowers, and cosmos are all good food sources for overwintering birds and small mammals. In return, these animals contribute their part by scattering seeds. Some of these will germinate, and the lifecycle starts anew. 

Self-Sowing

Dry calendula seeds are scattered across the ground, their dark, ridged surfaces contrasting with the earthy tones of the soil.
Allowing plants to self-sow saves money and enhances gardens.

Leaving your annuals in your beds can also save you money, as many of these plants will self-sow. If you cut them or pull these flowering plants out before they have the opportunity to drop their seeds, you will miss out on some delightful volunteers. 

Some are not prolific self-sowers, and for these, we will explore the other benefits of leaving them in place. Many, however, will drop their seeds, which get scattered by animals. Don’t be surprised to see some of these returning for a second season in the spring. 

We typically think of annuals as single-season or single-year inhabitants of the garden. In their natural environments, annuals survive by scattering their seeds. Otherwise, these single-year plants would die off in the wild. The same applies to your garden. 

Natural Mulch

Dried and withered plants fill a wooden raised garden bed, creating a textured layer of natural mulch that enriches the soil beneath.
Cut spent plants down and use them as mulch.

If you don’t love the look of dead foliage or your homeowner’s association objects, there are ways to work around disposing of your spent annuals entirely. You can still cut them off at the ground level and avoid the unsightly mess

Leaving the roots will serve their purpose whether the tops remain. While you’re at it, though, why not make good use of the leftover organic material? You can compost any healthy, non-diseased plant matter or turn it into mulch to protect perennials over the winter. 

If you want to make good use of healthy, decaying matter, cut your annuals to the ground. Then, use the tops of the plants to cover the ground. They will act like mulch, breaking down and enriching the soil over time. 

Drawbacks

There are exceptions to every rule, and sometimes, leaving your spent crops in the garden can be detrimental. Let’s talk about why you might want to clear the slate and pull up those annual plants.

Aesthetics

A woman in blue jeans and a plaid blue shirt, wearing grey gloves, uses pruning shears to remove dried plants from the garden.
Cut stems and mulch for a tidy, healthy garden.

The most obvious reason is for appearances. While you may value the benefits to letting your garden have a more natural overwintering period, your neighbors and HOA may feel otherwise. If you are working with a space that is visible to others, you may have to be creative with this. 

The good news is that you can cut the tops off and leave the roots intact. Those roots will still have all the same benefits: preventing erosion, feeding and maintaining the structure of the soil, and conserving resources. Just snip the stems off at the ground level and compost those that are healthy. 

If you want to go a step further, a healthy layer of mulch looks nice over the winter and has great benefits. Mulch also prevents erosion and breaks down over time, feeding the soil. 

Diseases

A farmer in high rubber boots carefully pulls out a plant showing signs of fungal disease from the garden.
Removing diseased plants protects future garden health and growth.

Another reason to pull those annuals is the presence of harmful pathogens and diseases. Winter weather may kill the host, but many of these diseases can lay dormant, only to flare back up and affect what you put in the ground next year. 

If you observe any signs of disease during the growing season, don’t bother trying to save them. It’s safer for the soil, as well as its current and future inhabitants, to remove the offending material and start over in the spring. The same goes for plants prone to diseases. Remove any debris from these plants as a preventative measure.

Pests

Fallen autumn leaves are scattered across the ground, speckled with small white pest eggs nestled on their surface.
Removing infested plants prevents pests from overwintering in gardens.

The same goes for any heavy pest infestations. Many garden pests overwinter in the larval or pupal stage. Leaving the infested foliage intact can mean providing a more hospitable place for those pests to survive. 

If you want to eliminate the possibility of pests next year, and that of potential disease, it’s best to pull everything. Don’t compost the materials, as this can contaminate your compost and spread the issues to other areas of the garden. Dispose of them away from other plants. 

Share This Post
The tall, spiky seed heads are composed of tightly clustered, dry brown blooms that create a striking silhouette against the green garden, providing a source of food for birds.

Gardening Tips

19 Perennial Seed Heads That Feed Garden Birds in Winter

Perennials die back during autumn leaving brown, dry stems and seeds behind. Let those seed heads stand and you’ll provide essential food sources for hungry birds. You’ll boost your backyard’s biodiversity with these 19 plants for feeding winter wildlife. Join native plant gardener Jerad Bryant on a tour of seed heads!

A shot of a garden using methods to protect crops frost

Gardening Tips

9 Smart Ways to Protect Your Tender Crops From Frost

Cooler weather is here, you’ve seen a frost warning, but you have tender annual herbs and vegetables in your garden. How can you protect them from the first few frosts? Gardening expert Liessa Bowen walks through 9 smart tips to help you protect your frost-sensitive crops from the next freeze.

A person wearing bright yellow boots stands on a bed of orange and brown fallen foliage, using an orange tool with wide plastic tines that are evenly spaced, gently moving through the dry foliage.

Gardening Tips

Should You Rake Leaves Off of Perennial Garden Beds?

Leaves are free sources of garden nutrients. Each autumn, they fall in thick layers, decorating lawns, beds, and containers. What should you do with them? Let’s see if we should rake them or leave them be. Join native plant gardener Jerad Bryant as we dive deep underground to see how leaves benefit the soil.

Close-up of three potted plants insulated for cold with burlap wrapped around the pots and fleece covering the plants in an autumn garden.

Gardening Tips

9 Clever Ways to Insulate Your Potted Plants in Cold Weather

Our container garden specimens are often too valuable to sacrifice to winter extremes. To get creative on preserving your favorites, employ crafty measures of insulated overwintering. Streamlined techniques using household and natural materials offer winter protection and may even promote an earlier spring reemergence. Gardening expert Katherine Rowe explores ways to enhance insulation for overwintering success.